Posts

Showing posts from March, 2021

Unity vs. Unity

It is undeniable that diversity is an integral part of our experience. The world we experience is marked by plurality and diversity. From a temporal standpoint, we begin with a diversity of things. There is a diversity of facts, events, mental states, objects, perceptions, beliefs, concepts, persons, etc etc. It is safe to say that our experience, in order to be what it is, must contain diversity. The question arises as to what can provide unity in our experience. As it turns out, if our experience consisted only of pure diversity, it would be unintelligible. In order to make sense of the world of experience, we must be able to find unity in the midst of the diversity. The human mind cannot but think in terms of unifying principles. Our minds are wired to order, organize, and categorize the different things we experience. If pure diversity were the case, we would be incapable of identification, predication, counting, using logic, applying moral principles, and so on. All these practice...

Sufficiency, Necessity, and Transcendental Arguments

One of the most foundational claims of the Van Tillian school of presuppositional apologetics is that the Christian worldview is the necessary precondition for the intelligibility of human experience. This means that the set of presuppositions that make up the Christian view of reality, knowledge, ethics, man, God, etc. are necessary for human experience to make sense. The claim is that we cannot make sense of the world, or know anything about it, without presupposing, at least implicitly, the Christian worldview. This is the so-called Transcendental Argument for God (TAG). This is a bold claim to say the least, and it has definitely not gone uncriticized. One of such criticisms concerns the mere sufficiency of the Christian worldview. Another such criticism is concerning the possibility of a uniqueness proof for the Christian worldview. These objections are not unique to TAG, though. They have their roots in the much broader list of objections raised against transcendental arguments i...